HomeInternational Geopolitics25 Million Uyghur Muslims Could Face The Heat As China Plans 'Soft...

25 Million Uyghur Muslims Could Face The Heat As China Plans ‘Soft Blasphemy’ Law: Opinion

Proposed changes to a Chinese public security law to criminalize comments, clothing, or symbols that “undermine the spirit” or “harm the feelings” of China have triggered the concern of legal experts in China, who say the amendments could be used arbitrarily.

China proposes a ban on clothing that ‘hurt nation’s feelings,’ confusing everyone. The proposed law does not explicitly define what actions or expressions would be considered in violation of the prohibiting law.

The contentious clauses of the draft law suggest that people found wearing clothing or symbols that “undermine the spirit or hurt the feelings of the Chinese nation” could face detention for up to 15 days and fines of up to 5,000 yuan (US$680).

Similarly, those who create or disseminate articles or speeches under this category could face the same punishment.

Questions Arise

The BBC reported that this move has raised concerns about potential repercussions and a lack of clarity regarding what constitutes a violation. This ambiguity has led to a chorus of voices, including social media users and legal experts, calling for greater transparency to prevent potential overreach and excessive enforcement.

Online discussions are rife with questions about how law enforcement authorities would determine when the “feelings” of the nation are “hurt.”

This ambiguity has led to concerns about potential abuse of power. For instance, one user on the Chinese social media platform Weibo questioned whether wearing a suit and tie, which has Western origins, could be construed as hurting national feelings.

For example, how will the law deal with the 25 million Muslim Uyghurs of Xinjiang whose males and females wear an attire that explicitly describes their ethnic, cultural, and social identity, which is different from that of the Hans (Han Chinese people)?

File Image: Uyghurs

Why is the Chinese male ruling clique fine with the dress of Western origin, but they will not allow the people to return to their classical attire? This appears to be a contradiction.

Legal experts within China have also expressed reservations about the vague language of the draft law. They argue that such ambiguity could infringe on personal rights and liberties.

Zhao Hong, a law professor at the Chinese University of Political Science and Law, highlighted the risk of law enforcers imposing their moral judgments beyond the scope of the law. She referenced a case from last year where a woman in a kimono was detained in Suzhou, sparking outrage on social media.

We are all aware of how the blasphemy law in Pakistan is frequently abused to the extent that a governor of Punjab province had to pay with his life for upholding humanistic tradition.  

The draft law exemplifies a broader trend in China under the leadership of President Xi Jinping. Since coming to power in 2012, Xi has sought to redefine what constitutes a model Chinese citizen.

This includes issuing “morality guidelines” in 2019, encouraging politeness and environmentally friendly travel while emphasizing loyalty to Xi and the Communist Party. The draft law reflects a continued push to regulate cultural expressions and behaviors.

Why The New laws

What necessitates bringing in new laws, particularly in public security? Where and how is China’s public security under threat, necessitating the imposition of curbs on civil and individual rights? Chinese civil society asks questions like these.

Similarly, BBC reported that China’s economy, the world’s second-largest, is facing its most serious setback in a generation. During the past two years, economic growth appears to have been cut nearly in half.

After emerging from the “Zero COVID” policies that Xi Jinping, China’s leader, ordered early in the pandemic, the country now faces a real-estate crisis and faltering confidence from its citizens and overseas businesses.

The problems have sparked debate among economists about whether Xi’s increasingly autocratic regime is to blame, and what a major slowdown could mean for the rest of the world,” wrote Isaac Chotiner in his article ‘Did authoritarianism cause China’s economic crisis?” in The New Yorker edition of September 7.

Xi Jinping
File Image: Xi Jinping


Amendments to public security laws could lead to more censorship. One person said on Weibo, “Today they can prevent you from wearing certain clothes, tomorrow they can prevent you from speaking, then the day after they can prevent you from thinking.” That is how totalitarianism works its way into a victimized society.

People question how law enforcers can unilaterally determine when the nation’s feelings are hurt. Controversial as the new laws are, these could be abused and used arbitrarily. 

The proposed legal changes also forbid “insulting, slandering or otherwise infringing upon the names of local heroes and martyrs” and vandalism of their memorial statues.

Thus, we find the administration wanting to reach far beyond the dress code and encompass various activities of the people routinely accepted in a regular democracy but taken as a threat to the very foundation of a totalitarian regime. To speak or write critically on the policy and planning of the government is a red rag to the bull.

By the standard outlined in the draft bill, will it also count towards hurting the spirit of the Chinese nation? The slew of proposed laws indicates confusion and chaos in the Chinese think tanks about reconciling Xi’s authoritarianism with the spirit of freedom straddling the entire Global South.

Source link
#Million #Uyghur #Muslims #Face #Heat #China #Plans #Soft #Blasphemy #Law #Opinion



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Aatmanirbhar Bharat


Swadeshi Empresa’s Fire Fighting Bots Gets Export Inquiries

Fire fighting bot developed by Swadeshi Empresa for the Indian Navy under the iDEX SPRINT initiative was handed over to INS Vikrant for user...

HAL’s trainer aircraft for pilots yet to get full certification after 6 months

Six months after the defence ministry signed a contract to procure HTT-40 basic trainer aircraft for the Indian Air Force, the aircraft is yet...

AMCA 5th Generation Stealth Fighter Updates

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Archive Months


Sri Lankan crisis a ‘serious’ matter, says EAM Jaishankar

Source : Asian News International (ANI)External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar in Thiruvananthapuram (Photo/ANI)Thiruvananthapuram (Kerala): External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Sunday called the economic...

Surveillance flights, not counterterrorism ops, restarted in Niger

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || ).push();The Pentagon said Thursday that it has not restarted counterterrorism operations in Niger, a day...

Wanted by NIA, Khalistani Terrorist Sukha Duneke Of Arsh Dalla Gang shot dead In Canada

 Source : ABP NewsKhalistani terrorist Sukhdul Singh, also known as Sukha Duneke -- who was part of the gang operated by Canada-based gangster Arsh Dalla,...

First MQ-9 drones to be delivered within four years of contract

New Delhi: India is finalising a Letter of Request (LoR) to the US for the acquisition of 31 MQ-9B Reaper drones. The deal for...

Vice Admiral briefed about progress on TEDBF design and Testbed, LCH in Indian Army livery found during his visit

Source : IgMp BureauVice Admiral Biswajit Dasgupta, AVSM, YSM, VSM, Flag Officer, Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Navy, Eastern Naval Command reviewed the progress of...

India to spend $30 billion to achieve independence on chip supply chain

Source : Indo-Asian News Service (IANS)Representative ImageIndia, which aims to become a global semiconductor hub in coming years, is set to pump $30 billion...

Malabar Exercise 2023: China to use Hundreds of its Low-Orbit Satellites to Spy On India-US-Japan-Australia Naval Drills

Source : The EurAsian TimesMalabar Exercise 2023: China to use Hundreds of its Low-Orbit Satellites to Spy On India-US-Japan-Australia Naval Drills While warships from India,...

The avoidable consequences of a government shutdown

As members of Congress return to the Capitol from the August work period at home with their constituents, only 11 joint legislative days remain...

Indian democracy in good health under Modi Govt, data presented by International critics shows signs of deception: Sydney-based academic

Source : Asian News International (ANI)Australian Academic Salvatore Babones believes India is in safe hands under PM Modi and slams the data by International...

Bharat Forge receives approval from MoD for procurement of 300 ATAGS, contract to be signed by year end

Source : Indian Defence Updates (IDU)Bharat Forge receives approval from MoD for procurement of 300 ATAGS, contract to be signed by year end Bharat Forge...

F-414 Enhanced engine variant won’t require any structural modification to be equipped on Tejas mk2 & TEDBF fleet: General Electric

Source : Indian Defence UpdatesRepresentative ImageGeneral Electric has submitted a proposal to co-developer 116 to 120 kilonewton engine with 100% transfer of technology for...

US Treasury official Wally Adeyemo says India ‘leader’ in digital economy

Source : Asian News International (ANI)US Deputy Secretary of Treasury, Wally Adeyemo at IIT Mumbai (Photo Credit: Twitter @TreasuryDepSec)Mumbai: US Deputy Secretary of Treasury,...

Border tensions between Afghanistan, Pakistan intensify

Source : Asian News International (ANI)Representative ImageVienna : Pakistan is facing an emerging security situation in its border provinces and an assertive Afghan Taliban,...

Russia unveils Kh-69 stealth cruise missile at Army 2022 Expo in Moscow

Source : Shepherd MediaThe Kh-69 cruise missile has a rectangular cross-section, implying a stealth capability. (Photo: Michael Jerdev)A new Russian stealthy airborne cruise missile,...

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker

Refresh Page
error: Content is protected !!