HomeIndian DefenceHC says person acquitted of moral turpitude cannot be denied appointment in...

HC says person acquitted of moral turpitude cannot be denied appointment in armed forces

msid 106861625,imgsize

A person, who has been acquitted in an offence of moral turpitude on the grounds of benefit of doubt, cannot be denied appointment in the armed forces, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has said. A single bench of Justice Jagmohan Bansal made this observation on a petition of Haryana resident seeking directions to set aside a March 2022 order cancelling his appointment to the post of a constable in the Indo-Tibetan Border Police Force (ITBP).

The court said it is a “well known fact that in our country it is very difficult to get a job especially a government job” and the denial of appointment to the petitioner ignoring that he was always bonafide and honest in disclosing his credentials would amount to indirect punishment for an offence in which he has been acquitted.

“In the present case, the respondent has not examined antecedents of the petitioner and his appointment letter has been cancelled on the sole ground that he was acquitted on the benefit of doubt,” the court said.

“The respondent has not considered nature of alleged offence, age of the petitioner and age of the prosecutrix at the time of alleged offence. The petitioner is not involved in any other offence and he has already been acquitted,” it said.

The petitioner was appointed to the post of constable in the ITBP on compassionate grounds in January 2022. However, his appointment letter was cancelled by authorities concerned after he disclosed that he was implicated in a criminal offence and was later acquitted.

In April 2018, the petitioner was booked for rape and also relevant sections of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) and the case was registered at police station Cheeka in Kaithal district of Haryana. However, the petitioner was acquitted of all charges by a Kaithal court in July 2019. In March 2022, the ITBP cancelled the appointment letter on the grounds that the petitioner was acquitted extending benefit of doubt. The petitioner’s counsel submitted that the complainant as well as her mother has stated that the petitioner has not committed the alleged offence.

The trial court had even recorded finding to the effect that the prosecution failed to prove age of the prosecutrix, which is necessary to invoke provisions of the POCSO Act.

The respondent cancelled the appointment letter on the grounds that the petitioner was involved in an offence of moral turpitude and he has been acquitted on the grounds of benefit of doubt.

There is no concept of honourable acquittal, the petitioner told the court.

However, the counsel for the Centre submitted that according to the 2012 instructions of the Ministry of Home Affairs, if there is acquittal on the grounds of benefit of doubt or where witnesses have turned hostile, a candidate shall generally not be considered suitable for appointment in the armed forces.

The petitioner was involved in an offence of moral turpitude, thus, the respondent was quite competent to reject claim of the petitioner, the counsel further submitted.

“The respondent is heavily relying upon instructions dated 01.02.2012 issued by Ministry of Home Affairs. As per instructions, if there is acquittal, a candidate who was implicated in an offence of moral turpitude, may or may not be appointed in the Armed Forces,” the court said.

In the instructions, the expression “generally” has been used which shows that there is no absolute bar on the appointment where acquittal is on the grounds of benefit of doubt. The competent authority in such cases can consider case of a candidate,” the court said.

The court directed the respondent to consider the case of the petitioner for appointment.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Aatmanirbhar Bharat

All

Defence manufacturer Bharat Electronics secures export order worth Rs 230 crore

State-owned aerospace and defence electronics company Bharat Electronics Limited (BEL) has obtained an export order worth Euro 25.75 million (estimated value of Rs 230...

Amid delays, HAL now aiming to deliver first LCA Mark 1A by August 15; GE engine supplies to start by September

Amid concerns over delays in the delivery of the first LCA Mark 1A fighter jet to the Indian Air Force, Hindustan Aeronautics Limited is...

AMCA 5th Generation Stealth Fighter Updates

AMCA to be integrated with sophisticated indigenous Distributed Aperture System (DAS) that making it a formidable air asset for the Indian Air Force

Source : IgMp Bureau Indiaโ€™s Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) is on the brink of a revolutionary transformation with the integration of a sophisticated Distributed...

AMCA to incorporate the best features of both 5th and 6th Generation fighters: ADA sources

Source : IgMp Bureau India's strides toward indigenous air dominance receive a substantial boost with the green signal for the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA)...

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Archive Months

Miscellanous

Ministry of Defence likely to clear โ‚น14,000 crore for the development of 4 prototypes of TEDBF

Source: The New Indian ExpressA fantastic artistic CGI of Indian Navy Twin Engine Deck Based Fighter (TEDBF) by Satwik SadhukhanThe Ministry of Defence is...

terrorism: NIA raids 44 locations in Karnataka, Maharashtra in ISIS terror conspiracy case

The National Investigation Agency (NIA) on Saturday carried out raids at 44 locations in Karnataka and Maharashtra in connection to an ISIS terror conspiracy...

Honeywell the maker of American Predator drone’s engine, to supply engine for India’s HALE UAV

Source : Indian Defence Updates (IDU)Representative ImageHoneywell Aerospace has said that it will be supplying its 940 horsepower TPE-33110 turboprop engine to Hindustan Aeronautics...

HAL looking at Automation technologies and outsourcing workload to Pvt companies to fast track Tejas Mark 2 program

Source : Indian Defence Updates (IDU) Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd (HAL) wants to reduce the manpower hours required for manufacturing Tejas Mark 2 fighter jets for...
Visits
error: Content is protected !!