HomeGlobal Defence UpdatesUS seizes initiative on space security for the first time in decades

US seizes initiative on space security for the first time in decades


Something very interesting has happened recently in the usually staid diplomatic world of outer space security. Part of it was almost expected: A two-yearlong, major multilateral process to discuss what to do about threats to space systems came to a conclusion without agreement on a way forward, or even on a summary report, partially due to bombastic diplomatic language from the Russian delegation. But along the way, a large number of countries outside the West, who have normally been critical of the U.S. position on these issues, responded positively to efforts from Washington to reshape the conversation out of the long-standing deadlock and toward progress on space security and stability.

For decades, the global diplomatic debate on space security issues has been stuck in neutral, going nowhere. The root cause was opposing views between the major players on what the biggest threat was to space security and stability, and how to address it. Russia and China argued that it was weapons placed in outer space, and proposed a new treaty banning them. The United States and its allies strongly opposed the draft treaty on the grounds that it was unverifiable and that there was no weaponization of space taking place.

In this debate, most developing countries tended to side with the Russian and Chinese position that weapons in space were the biggest issue, with the United States being cast as the main protagonist for the weaponization of outer space. Russia and China had the diplomatic upper hand, as they had proffered a draft treaty and could portray themselves as at least attempting to help, whereas the United States’ position was to oppose the draft Russia-China treaty without offering any alternatives.

As a result, the United States often found itself playing diplomatic defense on major votes on space security within the United Nations General Assembly.

That all began to change several years ago when the United States and its allies changed tack and began talking about space security not in terms of how to classify space objects as weapons but in terms of identifying behaviors deemed responsible — or not. That new approach helped lead to the creation of a new open-ended working group within the U.N. to discuss potential norms, principles and rules of behavior to reduce space threats that had widespread participation from more than 70 countries.

In April 2022, the discussion was really shaken up when the United States announced a voluntary commitment not to conduct destructive direct-ascent anti-satellite, or DA-ASAT, missile tests. Since then, 34 additional countries have joined in this voluntary commitment, and it has gained widespread international support.

In December 2022, the United States led a U.N. General Assembly resolution supporting the commitment not to conduct DA-ASAT missile tests, which overwhelmingly passed by a vote of 155 in favor, 9 against, and 9 abstentions. In this case, Russia and China, two of those voting against, were on the losing side of a major U.N. vote on space security.

This growing global focus on destructive DA-ASAT testing is in large part due to the long-lasting threat orbital debris from such tests pose to satellites operated by all nations. In the annual Global Counterspace Capabilities report that we co-edit, we document the more than 6,850 pieces of orbital debris created by destructive anti-satellite testing in space over approximately the last 60 years, of which more than 3,400 pieces are still in orbit and pose daily risks to critical satellites and human spaceflight. These tests have also created thousands of additional pieces of debris too small to be tracked that still could damage other spacecraft.

Destructive DA-ASAT testing is also an example of irresponsible behavior discussed by the open-ended working group on reducing space threats, which took place over four weeklong sessions in 2022 and 2023. While the group was unable to reach consensus on the final report, largely due to intransigence by the Russian delegation, the process had significant success. It socialized the idea of focusing on behavior. It brought many more countries into the discussion and popularized the role of non-legally binding instruments as one tool in an overall toolkit to bulwark space security.

And for the United States, it showed the value of participating in these discussions and putting legitimate proposals on the table, instead of just saying no to proposals it could not support.

It’s unclear what comes next for formal negotiations of space threats. Another U.N. process, this one focused firmly on the old-school space weaponization approach favored by Russia and China, gets underway in November and is unlikely to yield meaningful results. But for the United States, there is a clear opportunity to build on the growing global momentum created by its ground-breaking pledge. For the first time in decades, the world is on Washington’s side to help make space more secure and sustainable, if only it has the political will to lead.

Victoria Samson is a director at the Secure World Foundation. She previously served as a senior analyst for the Center for Defense Information. Brian Weeden is the director of program planning at the Secure World Foundation. He served as an officer in the U.S. Air Force working in space and intercontinental ballistic missile operations.

Source by [author_name]
#seizes #initiative #space #security #time #decades



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Aatmanirbhar Bharat


GRSE, Lloyd’s Register sign MoU for developing hydrogen fuel cell ferry

The public sector unit, at present, is working on a zero-emission passenger ferry, a prototype for future green vessels intended for use in the...

Indian Navy moves mega deal to buy second indigenous aircraft carrier

In a major push to the indigenisation in the military, the Indian Navy has moved a mega proposal to the government for building the...

AMCA 5th Generation Stealth Fighter Updates

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Archive Months


Indian Air Force Sukhoi Growler spotted during Exercise Ranvijay

Source : Indian Defence AnalysisIndian Air Force Sukhoi Growler spotted during Exercise Ranvijay The Battle domain of air superiority has shifted from dog fights and...

Russia launched Fierce Kinzhal Attack On Patriot SAM Battery In Kyiv; Aerospace War Heats Up In Ukraine

Source : The EurAsian TimesRussia launched Fierce Kinzhal Attack On Patriot SAM Battery In Kyiv; Aerospace War Heats Up In Ukraine Early morning on May...

Armenia sets its eyes over India made Akash SAM, Anti Drone system and Loitering Munitions

Source : IgMp BureauIndian weapons on which Armenia sets its eyesIndia Armenia defence partnership is booming at an unbelievable pace. As Russia is busy...

US and India Collaborate on unmanned surface vehicles (USVs) and unmanned underwater vehicles (UUVs) Defense Innovation with Indus-X

The US Department of Defense (DoD) has announced the inaugural meeting of the Indus-X Senior Advisory Group in partnership with the Indian Ministry...

PM Modi lays foundation of C-295 aircraft manufacturing facility in Vadodara

Source : Asian News International (ANI)Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the foundation stone-laying ceremony of C-295 transport aircraft manufacturing plant in Vadodara on October...

India dismisses reports of sending troops to Sri Lanka

Source : Asian News International (ANI)Photo: APColombo: The Indian High Commission in Sri Lanka on Sunday categorically dismissed “speculative media reports” about New Delhi sending...

DRDO starts development of new NASM-MR anti-ship missile for LCA Tejas

Source : IgMp BureauArtistic CGI of Naval Anti Ship Missile - Medium Range (NASM-MR) by Kuntal BiswasThe DRDO has started work on the Naval...

Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose – The man for whom the British left India; Nation bows down to its real ‘Father’, true ‘Superhero’

Source : Indus ScrollsNetaji Subhash Chandra Bose stands in front of the Cellular Jail at Andaman and Nicobar Islands, after its successful capture, on...

PM Modi’s determination not to allow normalisation of cross-border terror has shaped India’s Pak policy: EAM Dr. Jaishankar

Source : Press Trust of India (PTI)Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi (Left) and External Affairs Minister Dr. S. Jaishankar (Right) during a high-level cabinet...

Committed to continue positioning partnership with India at centre of its Indo-Pacific approach: Pentagon

Source : Press Trust of India (PTI)Representative ImageWashington: The US is committed to continue to position its relationship with India at the centre of...

Chinese ships enter Japan’s territorial waters near Senkaku islands

Source : Asian News International (ANI)Tokyo: Two Chinese vessels entered Japan's territorial water near the Senkaku Islands on Friday, pursuing two Japanese fishing boats in...

Cold War-era F-16, MiG-29 jets more relevant in ‘New Cold War’ than Stealth F-35, F-22 Raptor: Russian Expert

Source : The Eurasian TimesNeed, durability, practicality, socio-economy, and political economy, if not triumphs, takes precedence over technology. Put differently, when new technology emerges,...

Ukraine war inspires weapons that crack battle tanks at weakest point

LONDON — Western companies are developing weapons aimed at cracking battle tanks from the top, their weakest point, or that can rain down thousands...

HAL gets contract to supply 2 Dornier Multi Mission Maritime Patrol Aircraft to Indian Coast Guard

Source : Asian News International (ANI)HAL gets contract to supply 2 Dornier Multi Mission Maritime Patrol Aircraft to Indian Coast Guard New Delhi : The...

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker

Refresh Page
error: Content is protected !!
%d bloggers like this: